To the Superintendent and members of the Brookline School Committee,
We are parents, caregivers, and supporters of children in the Public Schools of Brookline. We write to show our support for PSB kindergarten teachers. We ask you to listen to them, take seriously their observations, expertise, and ideas, and act in the best interest of the youngest children in our schools.
We are concerned that classroom teachers, who work directly with our students and know them well, are finding that district mandated programs may be diminishing our children’s love of learning, and damaging their socio-emotional wellbeing.We hear that rigid, scripted, ever-increasing literacy blocks are crowding out time for play-based learning. Young children cannot be expected to sit still and to excel in desk-bound academics. We see in our own homes every day that they need to move, explore, interact and engage with the world. Why is the district requiring longer literacy blocks and “working snacks”? In some schools these blocks can be up to 90 minutes long, a tremendous amount of time in the instructional day when accounting for transitions, lunch, and specials. We are concerned that increased academic requirements are reducing the time available for play-based learning.
We are concerned when we hear teachers reporting that our children are showing increased anxiety as well. They are saying they can see behavioral problems rise as children are pushed away from play and towards rote academics. Research reflects this. Please see the work of Nancy Carlsson-Paige, an award-winning Massachusetts based researcher who has published many papers on the potentially detrimental effects of forcing children to learn to read too early (https://bit.ly/1FL9ExQ).
No child in the Brookline schools should ever say, “I’m not good at anything,” simply because we are asking them to do something they are not developmentally ready to accomplish. And yet this is exactly what kindergarten teachers are hearing from some of their students.
We are concerned that the focus on academic literacy out of synch with developmental readiness may be adversely impacting the most vulnerable students, undermining their confidence, especially when teachers are not allowed the flexibility to adapt to the student’s unique needs. On top of this, excessive data collection requirements are taking away time that teachers could spend working directly with their students or developing plans specific to the needs of their students. An example: the hours spent filling out progress reports that no parent can decipher is time spent away from teaching.
We support kindergarten teachers and their call to preserve play-based learning in Brookline. This is the direction many of the state’s best districts are moving in. There is an ample body of research that has repeatedly shown the power and importance of play in childhood learning. (Links to some of this research: https://bit.ly/2XEUxS5)
We also believe in the importance of choice time, to give our kindergartners the opportunity to spend time every day on activities that they choose and feel are fulfilling and empowering.
We urge the school committee to act in its capacity as representative citizen body to do what you can to return play, teacher creativity, and developmental readiness to the heart of our children’s kindergarten experiences. We ask you to find out why the district is moving away from play-based learning, and to ask our administrators what they can do to help reverse this trend.
When kindergarten teachers from across Brookline choose to speak in unison, for the sake of the children we put in their care, we must listen and act.
(You can add your signature here: https://forms.gle/ZTYgqY9phsaA92ww9)
Signed,
Benjamin Kelley
Meghna Chakrabarti
Carey B Goldberg
Stephanie Bruce
Lauren Bernard
Rebecca Manor
Lauren Bozzuto
Philippa Brousseau
priya raju
Brian Bozzuto
Leigha Cuniberti
Katja Vinha
Rengel Alexandra
Josie Petersen
Monica Gadaleta
Tali Frastai
Ayelet Geri
Alexa Martin
Emily Speicher
Sana Aiyar
Lisa Guisbond
Carolina Abuelo
Sarah Bookbinder
Trish Navarrete
Emily Sinagra
Mike Offner
Spence Merrow Paras
Emily Kitchings
Adam Weiner
Luciana Schachnik
Charu Swamy
Andrew Kitchings
Sarah Georgakopoulos
Berenika Voskoboynik
Ines Costa Dias
Katherine Butler
Tal Kenet
Kimberly Loscalzo
Nicholas Yoder
Anna Hartmann
Daria Mark
Nagmeh Ansari
Valerie Roth
Acacia Landfield
Jenny Searles Margulies
Andrew Becker
Mariah Nóbrega
Tamar Winter
Lonna Steinberg
Pete Paras
Erin Loparo
Peter Lahey
Joseph Loparo
Jennifer Barnes
Lara Jarrell
Patti Hartigan
Harmony Decosimo
Elizabeth Dupuy
De young
Lori Preston
Whitney
Susan Park
Megan Zorn
Jennifer Hughes
Ruth Kaplan
Kelly Tynan
suzette abbott
Benjamin Wish
Chitra Raju
Naama Gal
Sharon Imber
Marilyn Stein
Scott Jacobson
Erin Schroeder
Lynda Roseman
Amy climo
Mark Gerber
Jennifer Anderson
Barbara Lucchesi
Andrei Joseph
Shadi Johnston
Jennifer Debin
Susan Manaras
Susan Manaras
Jennifer Hunt
Morgan Esperance
Tania Schlatter
Patrick Esperance
Lindsey Hoffman
SARAH VARSANIK
Sarah Pickard
Matthew Mandel
Rachel Goldman
Rebecca Rabin
Michael Caltabiano
Karen Kariv
AMOL R YAJNIK
Patrick Barrett
Jessica Lodge
Leonardo Esperance
Nova Esperance
Darvensley Esperance
Julie Bedard
Alison Neal
Lauren Ruchelsman
Amy Chessia
Amy Chessia
Deborah Kobes
Bree Allen
Michele A Smith
Lynne Castronuovo
Cynthia McPherson
Corinna Pringle
Carrie Jacobs
Paula
Jeannine Randolph
Angela Pape
Elizabeth Pino
Jane Ellin
Shelly Magno
Carly Charalambou
Stephanie Rosenfield
Zong liu
Laura Baines-Walsh
Amy Feingold-Meyers
Jessica Silbey
Darvensley Esperance
Keri Hannagan
Elizabeth Ransom
Molly Cohen-Osher
Kirsten Waerstad
Elizabeth Ascoli
Mariela Ames
Marianna Drootin
Felice Friedman
Sharon McCarrell
Emily Mann
Mayeti Gametchu
Hedva Kobes
Elizabeth Bellis-Kates
Kornelia Polyak
Danna Perry
Carrie-Ann Kerwin
Deane Coady
Jaime Dasque
Simona Rits
Bill Schechter
Lorri Marek-Kagan
Lynn Modell
Kathleen Solomon
Tali Moreshet
Beth Boucher
Jennifer Englund
Ivan Zanoni
Amos Gutnick
Debra Abrams
Regina Glaser
Victoria Stockton
Elizabeth Crane
Melanie Sokol
Deb McCarthy
Michael DiClemente
Lauren Berry
Vanni Bucci
Mickie Dumont
Maggie Bowlby
Ran Margalit
Anat Biran
Susan Balogh
Angela Schena
Heather Green
Astrid Allen
Mary Beth Landrum
Cara Faria
Linda Eckersley
Lori B. Preston
Eric Edward Preston
Jessica Chicco
Amy Bolotin
Eileen Walfish
Jake Barrett
Keira Flynn-Carson
Bohn Buechner Whitaker
Lisa Nowak
Myra Goldberg
Cara Florance
Roohia Klein
Ellen Groustra
Kacie Bonin
Jason S Hellendrung
Kathryn Coronges
Anna Cowenhoven
Kaitlyn Lawrence
Cecilia Garcia Caballero
Meredith Wilson
Beth Gilligan
Erin Murphy
Geraldine McGlynn
Sara Mnookin
Meghan Cooper
Bambi Good
Erica Key
Maria Juliana Safar
Catherine Boucher
AMY Barsky
Melissa Foley
Sarah Ross
Lisa Pewitt
Britta Lassmann
Deborah Hatzieleftheriadis
Lanng Tamura
Michael Mello
K M Parker
Marcy Fischer
Alisa Conner
Sarah Frederick
Susan
Jeffrey Tiger
Cristina Toledo-Cornell
Lisa Ting
Amy Meunier
Kate Martin
Caitlin Studdard
Ginger Melton
Martha Leader
Laura Tarter
Angelica Rona
Amanda Zimmerman
Danielle Rabina
Susan Li.
Danielle Hannigan
Damien Thornton
Julia Lindenberg
Lucila Halperin
Catherine Burke
Vanessa Trien
Sarita Chung
Kim Sousa
Karyn Wergland
Adrienne Bowman
Daniel Verinder
Federica Piccioni
Celeste Finison
Kristine Knauf
Jean O'Halloran
Esther Leibel
Angie Schmider
Em Kessler
Robert Weintraub
Dianys Mendez
Ted M Lewis
Rebecca Weitz Shapiro
Richard Nangle
Jonathan Fine
Kathie Butler
Gretchen Tucker Underwood
Lauren Carroll
Brian Walsh
Joyce Jozwicki
Rebecca Selbak
Carol Schraft
Senofer Mendoza
Bita Tabesh
Yukiko Egozy
Karen Kuskin-Smith
Lisa Stahl
Kimberly Golden
Fiona Fennessy
Gill Simkiss
Sadra Isaacs
Kim Manasevit
Merav Shohet
Jessie Keppeler
Joanne Riley
Katharine Brooks Leness
Tony Leness
Ruth Kaplan
Petra G. Bignami
Sarah Giarrusso
Marissa Maki
Sara Schoenfeld
JAMES C.Cradle
Marc Wein
Kathleen McKenna
Laura Weinstein
Adrian Bignami
Kaitlyn Cahill
Leslie O'Toole
Vikas Anand
Jennifer Carballo
Andrew Mullins
Sara S Gewurz
Carolina Celaro
Igor Muravyov
Sam Schneider
Eva Nikovski
Ginny Friedman
Diane Lande
Erin Solovey
C. Scott Ananian
Donna de Foleschampe
Howard Shen
Sean G Megason
Ai-Chun Cheng
KARA SALVI
Tammy Johns
Maayan Landy
Duke vo
Michael Strunk
Alex Loscalzo
Kayla Schwartz
Deb Becker
Lauren Stern
Cher Duffield
Kimberly Rowell
April Silbert
Carole Seigel
Christina Harris
Amanda Livengood
Jonathan Ross
Amanda Weeden
Nicole Connors
Lauren Harrison
Jennifer Papasodoro
Sara O'Brien
Shelly Chin
Francesca Pontiroli
Anna Hughes
Robert Mallery
Katherine Ingraham
Jane Kanarek
Amanda Gordon
Athena Rodriguez
Audrey Lee
Eric Stamp
rebecca manor
Laura Gurry
Bridget Muelbert
Jenny Tam
Margaret Lai
Jayne E. Kerner
Erika White
Mark Goldner
Dominique Gonyer
Jocelyn Guggenheim
Tracy McNeal
Elizabeth Solinga
Janet Cline
Lyndsey Niehus
Margaret Evans
Cristina Moreira
Ross Knights
Dorothy Lebach
Christine Rogers
James B Rogers
Cornelia van der Ziel
Kathleen May
Phoebe Segal
Joeanna McPherson
Bruce Mallory
Hannah Dalpiaz
Christine Zu Ermgassen
Cathleen Aron Schoen
Katia Wish
CHARA PANTAZI
Deborah Costolloe
Leslie Spaneas
Agnès Albérola
Marcia Hnatowich
Emily McGinnis
Alisa Ridruejo
Don Hnatowich
Russ Cox
Gili Naveh
Shuai Zhang
Gina Vargus
Martin Sleeper
Anna Garza-Mayers
Alexander Bockman
Robert Solinga
Joshua Paul Dupuy
Rachel Huckfeldt
Bill Schechter
Marie-Christine Harvey
Sarah Shalek
Pat Vonnegut
Bree Ojeda
Kelly Quaye
Lauren Knighton
Claire Vogel
Yuval Hart
Nira Pollock
Emily Lyettefi
Kristin Hung
Andréa Bleichmar
Yana Huss
Carol Savage
Wesley Schwartz
Shan Liu
Karine Gibbs
Jules Milner-Brage
Rachel Tseng
Patrick Feeney
Philipp
Teresa Torchia
Alexander Tsai
Ian Johnston
SUSAN D HOWARD
Christina Harris
Felipe Genoveze
Steven Ehrenberg
Jen Reed
Philip Abrams
Alain Jehlen
Meighan Rock
Abby Johnson
Marie A. Gardiner
Anastasya Partan Tveteraas
Susan Gauss
Ellen Goldberg
Nella LaRosa-Waters
David Russell
Susan Zeiger
Yen-Lin Chen
Kate Jones
Stephanie Mullins
Rubén Arnao Rodriguez
Elizabeth Percy
Rachel
Liz Donovan
Catherine bernard
Nicole Maclay
Melodie Jeffery-Cassell
Jennifer Kerner
Jonathan Kerner
Melissa Bird
david Klafter
Yo-EL Arnaldo Cassell
Vaishali Kushwaha
Sheila Kaspik
Stephen Vogel
Mari Kotlov
Olivia Reyelt
Manolis Kellis
Charles Taylor
Sheri Simmons
Joanna Davidson
Karen A Galbraith
Byron Galbraith
Christi Electris
Christine Lilienfeld
Maureen Fallon
Hillary Zahm
Sherry Flashman
Anna Healy
Margarita Perez
Rose Avakian
Fauzia Rashid
Nancy Harlow
Gayle L
Emily Dolbear
Sheryl McGovern
Maria Leuner
Annelena Lobb
Elizabeth Schafer
Sean McMahon
Maggie Shirland
Mark Leuner
Stephanie Cohen
Robin Brooks
stacey batista
Kristie McElhaney
Sameer Upadhyay
Nora Keenan
Jennifer Anders Katz
Toby Raybould
Terese Romano
Kha Dickerman
Jeff walker
Pam Fiorelli
JENNIFER AMIGONE
Michael Desai
Dean Lyettefi
Ana Otero
Anna Asphar
Tiffany Rinne
Youly Diamanti-Karanou
Eva Lundsager
Veronique Corrdin
Lena Berc
Caitlin Vaughn
Brian O'Halloran
Serena Parekh
Gillian Webster
Krista McDowell
Ann Goebel-Fabbri
Leah Harsfield
Laurie Lasky
Sarah Bob
Paula Rogovin
Nancy Pronovost
Hilary Elkins
Monica Tovar
Margaret Farnan
Christina Lee
Ryan Wenk
Jennifer Conner
Jennifer Adler
Peggy Campion
Lee L. Selwyn, TMM Pct. 13, Member, Advisory Committee
Vanisha Bapat
Roger Grande
Mary Jo
Richard Levy
Tung Lee
Barr and Joyce Jozwicki TMM pct 9
Melissa Hale Woodman
Manjari Miller
Kristina Tobey
Virginia Smith
Jeremy Bloch
Martha Caron
Dirk R Englund
Clint Richmond
sofia gertsberg
Annie Rotner
Lisa Yuen
Kevin Rhoads
Paul Warren
Helen Haller
Leena Mittal
Melissa Finkelstein
Michelle Simon
Julia H Farago
Maya Norton
Peter Fuller
Sarah Zimman
michelle morgenstern
Sharon Gilad-Gutnick
Michelle Morgenstern
Deb Allen
shula gilad
Shai Schubert
Mrs. Hillary Shivers
Carlos Ridruejo
Charles Morgan, Ph.D.
Charles Morgan
Amy Rugel
Meg Taylor
Kirsten Lockwood
Jane Flanagan
Nancy Gutmann
Kimberly Arkin
Shalev Gilad
joshua paris
Melissa Gallin
Christine M Potts
NICHOLAS ROTHSTEIN
Randa Reitman
John Gunning
Maureen McKeon
Christine Langhoff
Maryanne Senn
Melissa Dulla
Rob Schoen
Susan Faja
Adam Faja
Savyon Cohen
Yuling Zhang
Archana Basu
Barbara Gutman
Janice S. Kahn
Rupa Cornell
Britt leon
Michelle Mund
Susan Linn